Mel Valentin, Author at That Shelf

Mel Valentin

Senior Critic

Mel Valentin has been writing about his first and possibly his last love, film, for more than a decade. Born somewhere on the East Coast in the last century, Mel moved to the San Francisco Bay Area two decades ago. Mel spends his days looking forward to when we can all return to movie theaters and film festivals in person.

Articles by Mel Valentin:

February 7, 2025
Love Hurts Review: Ke Huy Quan Gets the Lead Role He’s Always Deserved but It Disappoints
Love Hurts underuses and disappoints Ke Huy Quan (and his goodwill-generating performance) in his first lead role.

January 17, 2025
Wolf Man Review: The Reboot Starts Promisingly, Ends With a Whimper
Leigh Whannell’s latest addition to the Universal Monsters universe, Wolf Man, starts strong, but ends with a whimper.

December 26, 2024
Better Man Review: Simian Simulacrum Replaces Robbie Williams in Refreshingly Unconventional Biopic
Better Man replaces pop star Robbie Williams with a simian simulacrum in this refreshingly unconventional biopic.

December 23, 2024
Babygirl Review: Nicole Kidman and a Committed Cast Rejuvenate the Erotic Thriller
Nicole Kidman and Halina Reijn offer an invigorating and provocative drama about a CEO who risks all for an affair in Babygirl .

December 14, 2024
Nickel Boys Review
RaMell Ross’s adaptation of Colson Whitehead’s novel Nickel Boys stuns, impresses, and amazes in equal measure.

November 28, 2024
Moana 2 Review: Disney’s Sequel Underwhelms and Disappoints
Moana 2’s predictably stellar animation can’t save it from an underwhelming storyline or underdeveloped characters.

October 27, 2024
Venom: The Last Dance Review: Once More, But With Less Feeling
Tom Hardy returns as one-man buddy duo in Venom: The Last Dance , the latest entry in the shockingly successful branch of the MCU.

October 14, 2024
Hold Your Breath Review: Not Even Sarah Paulson At Her Best Can Save This Psychological Horror Flick
A welcome star vehicle for Sarah Paulson, Hold Your Breath starts strong, but never recovers from a repetitive, undernourished script.

October 5, 2024
The Killer’s Game Review: Talented Cast Wasted in Dull, Unimaginative Actioner
A disappointing waste of Dave Bautista’s talent, The Killer’s Game won’t be high on anyone’s career retrospective.

September 19, 2024
Never Let Go Review: Halle Berry Commits in Post-Apocalyptic Horror
Halle Berry stars as a mother who protects, and then threatens, her family in Alexandre Aja’s horror flick Never Let Go .

September 6, 2024
The Front Room Review: Provocative, Transgressive Domestic Horror
Spiked with darkly inflected humor that borders on the offensive, The Front Room represents Max and Sam Eggers willingness to provoke audiences.

August 10, 2024
It Ends With Us Review: Not Even Blake Lively Can Save This Disappointing Melodrama
Not even a career-best Blake Lively or her splendid fits can save this lacklustre adaptation of Colleen Hoover’s bestseller, It Ends With Us.

August 4, 2024
Trap Review: M. Night Shyamalan’s Serial Killer Entry Delivers Chills and Thrills
M. Night Shyamalan’s serial killer entry, Trap, delivers thrills and chills in equal measure.

July 19, 2024
National Anthem Review: A Refreshingly Unique Queer Coming-of-Age Story
Luke Gilford’s impressive first feature National Anthem takes audiences inside the world of queer rodeos.

July 13, 2024
Fly Me to the Moon Review: Old-School Rom-Com Just Misses the Target
Greg Berlanti’s Fly Me To The Moon coasts on the outsized charms of its leads, Channing Tatum and Scarlett Johansson.

Search for:
Instagram
@thatshelf
THAT SHELF
@thatshelf
Film 🎥 TV 📺 Music 🎶 Podcasts 🎧 Contests 🏆 — News, reviews, interviews! —
View on Instagram

@thatshelf

•

Follow

The Social Reckoning revisits the world of Facebook, following data scientist Frances Haugen and Wall Street Journal journalist Jeff Horwitz as they investigate the company’s role in spreading harmful content and radicalizing users. Set between 2019 and 2021, the film examines the consequences of prioritizing profit over people in the social media industry. Despite tackling an urgent and relevant subject, Aaron Sorkin’s follow-up struggles to offer fresh insights into the damage caused by social media. While the story raises important questions about corporate responsibility and the power of technology, underdeveloped characters, an awkward central relationship, and uninspired direction prevent the film from reaching its full potential. 📝 Full review by Mel Valentin now up on That Shelf (and at the link in our bio).
4 hours ago
View on Instagram |
1/9

@thatshelf

•

Follow

Six seasons into Slow Horses, Gary Oldman continues to find new layers in Jackson Lamb, the sharp-tongued, dishevelled spy at the centre of the series. In conversation with That Shelf at TIFF, Oldman reflects on playing Lamb over multiple seasons, the character’s history and hidden vulnerabilities, and the parallels between Lamb and another of his iconic spies, George Smiley. He also shares how adapting Mick Herron’s novels allows him to keep discovering new details about a character who carries years of history and baggage. 📝 Full interview by Pat Mullen now up on That Shelf (and at the link in our bio).
1 day ago
View on Instagram |
2/9

@thatshelf

•

Follow

Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother follows Latif, a devout Muslim and hitman whose life takes a turn after his wife’s death leaves him caring for their three children. With his infant refusing formula and their supply of breast milk running out, Latif must navigate a dangerous world of crime and violence while trying to provide for his family. Mahershala Ali delivers an extraordinary performance in this striking blend of crime thriller, dark comedy, and religious parable. Bassam Tariq explores faith, fatherhood, hypocrisy, and forgiveness without losing sight of the tenderness at the film’s heart. Despite some uneven pacing near the end, it’s a bold, moving, and unforgettable film that stands apart from anything else this year. 📝 Full review by Lyle Kruger now up on That Shelf (and at the link in our bio).
2 days ago
View on Instagram |
3/9

@thatshelf

•

Follow

Eva Marie Saint, one of the last silver-screen icons, has passed away at 102. She burst onto the scene with a magnificent supporting role opposite Marlon Brando in On the Waterfront — a role that earned her a Best Supporting Actress Oscar. She went on to memorable parts in North by Northwest, Raintree Country, The Man in the Gray Flannel Suit, Summer and Smoke, Exodus, and The Rainmaker. Her more recent roles included parts in Winter's Tale, Because of Winn-Dixie, and Superman Returns. Originally from Newark, she auditioned for Elia Kazan and was accepted into the Actors Studio, becoming one of a new generation of strong, method actors. One of the last of her Hollywood generation, she leaves us with an impressive career and legacy of over 6 decades! RIP.
6 days ago
View on Instagram |
4/9

@thatshelf

•

Follow

ENTER FOR YOUR CHANCE TO WIN TICKETS TO SEE #THESOCIALRECKONING! Inspired by true events and the whistleblower who started the social media reckoning we’re seeing play out today, this Aaron Sorkin original screenplay is a companion piece to the hit film The Social Network and a true David and Goliath story. Frances Haugen (Madison), a young Facebook engineer, enlists the help of Jeff Horwitz (White), a Wall Street Journal reporter, to go on a dangerous journey that ends up blowing the whistle on the social network’s most guarded secrets. Follow the instructions below, and you'll be entered to win tickets to see the film when it hits theatres on October 9th, courtesy of @sonypictures, @thetarogroup and That Shelf! 📱 Follow That Shelf, 📱 Like this post, 📱 Tell us your favourite based-on-a-true-story movie, and, 📱 Tag the friend you'll bring with you to the movie! @TheSocialReckoning debuts exclusively in movie theatres on October 9, 2026. Giveaway closes on October 7 at 11:59 ET. Open to Canadian residents only. One entry per person. #giveaway #canadacontest #movietickets
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
5/9

@thatshelf

•

Follow

CONTEST: ENTER FOR YOUR CHANCE TO WIN TICKETS TO BRAZIL FILM FEST That Shelf, and @brazilfilmfest want to send you and a friend to see the best of Brazilian cinema in Toronto! 🗓️ Film 1 - Malês (Oct 9, 11 am) 🗓️ Film 2 - Zico, the Samurai of Quintino (Oct 9, 2 pm) 🗓️ Film 3 - The Noise of the Night (Oct 9, 4:45 pM) 🗓️ Film 4 - If I Were You 3 (Oct 10, 11:15 am) 🗓️ Film 5 - The Crime Genius (Oct 11, 11 am) Here's how to enter: 🇧🇷 Follow us and @brazilfilmfest 🇧🇷 Like this post 🇧🇷 Tell us which film you'd like to attend, and 🇧🇷 Tag a friend October 9–11, 2026 📍 TIFF Lightbox | Toronto 🎟️ Tickets & festival details: brazilfilmfest.ca Giveaway closes on October 7. Open to Canadian residents only. Winners will be contacted via DM. 🗓️ Film 1 - Malês (Oct 9, 11 am) Malês is a powerful story of resilience and courage set against the vibrant backdrop of Salvador in 1835. Torn from their homeland in Africa during their wedding ceremony, two young Muslims are enslaved in Brazil. Separated by a cruel fate, they struggle to survive and find one another again as they become caught up in the largest enslaved uprising in Brazilian history: the Malê Revolt. 🗓️ Film 2 - Zico, the Samurai of Quintino (Oct 9, 2 pm) An original portrait of the life and career of Arthur Antunes Coimbra—better known as Zico. The Samurai of Quintino explores the many dimensions of one of football's greatest legends, revealing the unique personality behind the icon. Drawing on Zico's personal archive—made public for the first time—the documentary weaves together stories from his remarkable journey with Flamengo, the Brazilian National Team, and Japan. Featuring Ronaldo Nazário, Maestro Júnior, friends, and family, the film offers an intimate look at the man behind the legend, leading to a surprising encounter with the "Spirit of Zico": an identity as fascinating as it is paradoxical, forged in the suburbs of Rio de Janeiro, yet shaped by values and discipline that found their perfect match in Japan. 🗓️ Film 3 - The Noise of the Night (Oct 9, 4:45 PM) Sônia is a woman who has spent her life burying the wounds of her childhood, feeling unseen and forgotten by her husband
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
6/9

@thatshelf

•

Follow

Verity follows struggling writer Lowen, who is hired to finish the latest book in bestselling author Verity Crawford’s series after an accident leaves her unable to communicate. But while staying at Verity’s home, Lowen discovers a disturbing manuscript that forces her to question everything she knows about the author, her family, and the truth behind what happened. With Anne Hathaway clearly having fun in the title role, Verity embraces the pulpy spirit of ’90s psychological thrillers while balancing darker themes with a playful sense of humour. Dakota Johnson and Josh Hartnett add strong performances, but it’s Hathaway’s larger-than-life presence and the film’s twists that make this a fun, unpredictable ride. 📝 Full review by Rachel West now up on That Shelf (and at the link in our bio).
1 week ago
View on Instagram |
7/9

@thatshelf

•

Follow

Primetime takes a dark look at the rise of To Catch a Predator, following disgraced journalist Chris Hansen and the sensationalist television empire built around his “gotcha” investigations. Through the eyes of the people working behind the scenes, the film explores the blurred lines between journalism, entertainment, morality, and the pursuit of ratings. Robert Pattinson delivers a complex performance as Hansen, capturing both his commanding television persona and the contradictions beneath it. With its gritty late-2000s aesthetic and echoes of Network, Primetime becomes a sharp moral fable about the damage caused when sensationalism, ambition, and the desire for authority take priority over empathy and justice. 📝 Full review by Pat Mullen now up on That Shelf (and at the link in our bio).
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
8/9

@thatshelf

•

Follow

Forgotten Island follows best friends Jo and Raissa as their final night together before graduation takes an unexpected turn, transporting them to the mythical island of Nakali. There, they face memory-stealing creatures, magical obstacles, and the possibility that returning home could mean losing the memories of their friendship. Fast, chaotic, and packed with Filipino mythology and pop culture influences, the film embraces its sensory overload rather than slowing down. Its kinetic animation, vibrant visual style, and spirited voice cast make for an exhilarating adventure, while at its heart is a moving story about friendship, growing up, and holding on to the memories that shape us. 📝 Full review by Pat Mullen now up on That Shelf (and at the link in our bio).
2 weeks ago
View on Instagram |
9/9