The premise is pretty much in the title. Hannah (Leighton Meester) is a skilled private bodyguard who’s tasked with watching over People’s Sexiest Man Alive, Jack Stapleton (Jared Padalecki), as he heads home to Montana for the holidays.
Guarding Stars has a lot that fits snugly in the cheese-fuelled Christmas romance genre. A sick mother (Andie MacDowell) who’s relying on the holiday spirit to keep her going, and even distant siblings who’ve drifted further apart ever since their brother’s passing. At the centre are a tightly wound businesswoman and a guy who’s both a snobby celebrity and an easygoing farm boy. Their very different personalities clash when they (of course) have to play nice and pretend to be a couple.
The whole thing sounds like one big cliché.
And it would be, if not for the silly but fun B-movie action thrown into the wintry love story. It’s refreshing to see a romance movie rely on a plot device outside of adultery, a couple’s spat, or an infamous love triangle for its central conflict. The driving tension of Guarding Stars isn’t about whether Hannah and Jack will fall for each other–it’s about whether or not they’ll, quite literally, survive this visit home.
Jack has a stalker, and so the duo must try to keep a low profile. Visiting home after a long time away is hard enough, but it’s even harder when one returns to the fold as a superstar. Hannah senses threats of violence around every corner, but she has to hide her quite justifiable paranoia. After all, Jack’s mom is very sick, and she can’t handle anything stressful–including the fact that a security detail was sent to protect her son from an on-the-loose sociopath.
Guns are shot, fight scenes unfold, and epic vehicular stunts are inevitable. Making Guarding Stars entertaining both for a hopeless romantic and their rom-commed-out partner.
The acting, both funny and emotional, meets expectations. Whenever MacDowell shows up, a good time is guaranteed, and Meester and Padalecki’s chemistry is genuinely good. Their characters feel more fully realized than the average opposites-attract duos, but the dead-mom backstory and broken-brother bond don’t add as much as they maybe should to the overall proceedings.
When the dialogue isn’t mushy, it’s pretty witty and highlights each character’s distinctive voice–Hannah’s in particular. She starts off speaking short, punchy sentences that sound overly formal and cliched, e.g., “The object of personal security is to anticipate a threat before it happens.” But as the movie progresses, the bodyguard slowly sheds her technical jargon and uptight manner and reveals her softer, human side.
The visuals don’t quite live up to the rest of Guarding Stars. Save for a few shots of the majestic white mare, Bonnie, galloping through crisp Montana snow, everything else looks very Netflix original. The sets suffer, too. The worst offender is the Stapleton family ranch, a picture-postcard New-England farmhouse with a coat of red paint that’s far too fresh. Not to mention those suspiciously Christmas-ready green windowsills.
The soundtrack, too, leans heavily on the season. Which is to be expected. But instead of some classic, well-loved, traditional melodies, the film relies on B-level holiday pop songs like “Fancy Like Christmas”. It would’ve been nice, and more fitting, to maybe hear a mix of the two.
Digressions aside, this is a feel-good story. It wants to give people fuzzy feelings and–though it does deliver a solid climactic twist with the stalker B plot–it doesn’t promise anything beyond that. And it doesn’t need to.
“You are the star of the movie. Go give it a Hollywood ending,” MacDowell’s character says to her heartbroken son when he and Hannah push the will-they-won’t-they to a breaking point and end up miles apart the day before Christmas. And like all films of this type, a happy ending is the only ending! Because this is a love story, and doubly because this is a Christmas love story.
The final scene takes place a year later, with Jack screening his newest movie at home on the Stapleton ranch. It’s about his and Hannah’s fairytale get-together, the one the audience has just watched–and, in a jest of the film’s very premise, Jack’s family hates it.
Overall, Guarding Stars is exactly what it’s supposed to be: a lively Christmas flick that wraps up nicely with a neat little bow. And it’s exactly what the doctor ordered if this is your jam.
Guarding Stars is currently streaming on Netflix.