Madden Review: Russell Fumbles a Legend’s Bio-pic

Russell fumbles it

David O. Russell’s latest film (say it with me, people) is “based on a true story.” It charts John Madden’s years as the Oakland Raiders’ head coach, a TV broadcaster, and the inspiration for Madden NFL video games. Madden was a legendary figure in the National Football League (NFL) community. He coached the Raiders from 1969-78 and won the franchise its first Super Bowl title in 1976. He famously never had a losing season during his NFL career. Among coaches who lasted at least 100 games, his .763 regular-season winning percentage is still the highest. The Raiders coach prematurely retired due to burnout and a bleeding ulcer—attributable to years dealing with Raiders owner Al Davis (Christian Bale). It’s easy to see how, without his condition, Madden would’ve coached for decades and retired happily. But then we wouldn’t have the cultural legacy of his other endeavours.

Now, your average moviegoer won’t remember Madden (Nicolas Cage) for his coaching years. If they’re young enough, they might not even know about his decades of colourful commentary. But his name will live on in video games. EA Sports is one of the highest-earning entertainment companies on Earth, thanks largely to the popularity of Madden NFL games. EA founder Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney) approached Madden about the game in 1984, but Madden’s insistence on realism meant the game didn’t debut until 1988. The development team, led by Hawkins, sees an easy opportunity to cut down players, but Madden refuses. Watching Cage blow up at video game technicians for removing linemen from his namesake game is ridiculously fun.

At first glance, Nicolas Cage’s presence here seems odd. Mandy, Longlegs, and Surfer highlight Cage’s nouveau shamanic portrayals, but John Madden doesn’t really fit into that type of performance. Madden was a warm and sometimes rambling man. His confidence inspired others to be their best. He was never afraid to speak his mind, and viewers loved him for it. Luckily, Cage’s prosthetics don’t inhibit him while acting, but they also don’t do much to make him resemble Madden, either. The voice approximation isn’t close, but it avoids parody. Jeremy Strong’s portrayal of Mark Zuckerberg in The Social Reckoning was very accurate, but it also invited laughter. By comparison, I think Cage made the right choice.

Madden’s time in the booth with legendary partner Pat Summerall (Joel Murray) lasted longer than any other broadcasting duo, covering over 20 years of games. Murray doesn’t get lost trying to do an impression of Summerall, instead leaning into the dry wit and reserve that Madden’s partner was known for. Cage, of course, has no problem recreating highly animated, roundabout analysis that Madden was known for. His mid-game scribblings are still popular on YouTube. If it’s not clear that Madden is closer to a broad comedy than a portrait of a man’s life, the multiple scenes of the figure drawing things on the TV monitor will inform audiences. Madden and Summerall were the premier coverage team because, despite the shtick, he knew football in his bones and related that to the average viewer. His football acumen was unparalleled. The depth goes by the wayside for jokes.

One hopes that the combined talents of Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale would be enough to recommend Madden. I really did. Bloggers were concerned when Madden was sent directly to streaming. It must be an indictment of the film’s quality, they said. Turns out, they were right. The tone of the film never comes together.

The problem starts and ends with Russell’s script, co-written by Cambron Clark. John Madden isn’t like the high-octane eccentrics Russell builds films around. Silver Linings Playbook and American Hustle were critical darlings, though Joy and Amsterdam quashed Russell’s box-office prospects. With Madden, I suspect he’s making one for Amazon before he tries his luck again. Amazon is clearly going for something more family-friendly, but that’s not Russell’s wheelhouse. And he’s made something that veers into Al Davis’s irritating histrionics rather than Madden’s legacy. Farcical moments presented side-by-side with serious medical episodes can induce whiplash. Especially with jarring breaks in the fourth-wall with Cage and Bale glancing right into the camera à la The Office.

Kathryn Hahn and Sienna Miller play the wives, Virginia Madden and Carol Davis. Most biopics don’t give the wives anything to do. Unfortunately, that trend continues here. Hahn is usually so funny, so it’s a waste of her talent to saddle her with dialogue that feels ripped from a SNL parody of The Sopranos.

Bale gets the easier task of playing the flamboyantly arrogant Al Davis. His role is smaller than advertised, but Bale commits, ranting and raving like his Academy Award-winning turn as Dicky Eklund in The Fighter. The costuming and hairstyling are spot-on. The mantra of “just win, baby” defined Davis’s entire life, and Bale leans into the larger-than-life personality of the unruly owner that was personified with antics like wasting Marcus Allen’s prime years, publicly shaming coaches, and pioneering tactics for owners to hold cities hostage for new stadiums. When Bale is onscreen as Davis, Russell seems motivated. It makes one wonder why he didn’t just make Davis the focus.

Credit where credit is due, however. Not since Any Given Sunday has a filmed football looked this real. Russell captured the authenticity of early 2000s boxing matches on HBO for The Fighter, and he simulates the NFL games effectively. The score, by Marcelo Zarvos, is filled with rousing music that perfectly complements the Raiders’ march to the Super Bowl. If Madden had played it straightforward more often, it may have still gone to theatres.

Madden should’ve been a feel-good film timed perfectly for families to watch around the holidays. Russell’s past films (The Fighter, Silver Linings Playbook) indicate that he understands the assignment. Yet he can’t help but lean into the bizarre comedy stylings that define his career. Even the decidedly Thanksgiving-hungover football fans who stream the film will have no idea what to make of it.

Madden debuts on Prime Video November 18.



Advertisement