LEONARDO SBARAGLIA as Raúl in BITTER CHRISTMAS, Photo Copyright El Deseo. Photo by Iglesias Más. Courtesy of Sony Pictures Classics

Bitter Christmas Review: The Hard Truth About Repeating Yourself

Pedro Almodóvar delivers a suprisingly inert film

Bitter Christmas marks something of a surprise from Pedro Almodóvar. The Spanish auteur delivers a lump of coal with this award season offering. Bitter Christmas serves a rare flop in the career of one of cinema’s greatest voices on the heels of a late-career grand slam that includes the Oscar-nominated Pain & Glory and Parallel Mothers, and the Golden Lion winner The Room Next Door. Hot streaks inevitably cool.

One can’t help but harp on Bitter Christmas since it is, after all, a film about filmmaking. A signature Almodóvar surrogate comes in the form of Leonardo Sbaraglia as Raúl, a filmmaker who clacks out a screenplay in 2026. Raúl summons currents of inspiration for his latest story about a woman writing a screenplay in 2004. She, too, cribs from the lives of others. In both cases, the filmmaker characters learn hard truths that making art from life necessitates a bit more inspiration than changing peoples’ names.

The movie within the movie stars Barbara Lennie as Élsa, who twists her girlfriends’ stories into loosely fictional tragedies. All the while, she copes with crippling panic attacks. They’re like manifestations of the anxiety that her thievery will be found out.

Élsa’s tale weaves in an out of its own dance with past and present tense as Raúl writes and revises her story. He gives her narrative flashbacks of its own as Elsa looks back for inspiration. That largely comes from her stripper/firefighter boyfriend, Bonifacio, played by Patrick Criado, whose casting at least shows that Almodóvar hasn’t lost his fine eye for aesthetics. Every scene of Bitter Christmas pops with colour and beautiful people—a few Almodóvar regulars were clearly gifted with Ozempic last holiday season—so hints of the great filmmaker do appear. Nobody composes a frame with more vibrant shades and hues than Pedro does. Few maestros have such a knack for revealing character through interior decorating.

However, and there’s always a however these days, the story lacks the same vibrancy. Films about writers need more than onscreen text to add the “motion” to motion pictures. It’s a lot of people sitting around and typing, often reading their words aloud. Bitter Christmas plays very much like a movie from the dawn of email. Dramatically, it’s inert, something that even the incredibly talky Room Next Door managed not to be.

The actors lack the meaty material to work with as Julianne Moore and Tilda Swinton did in that chatty affair. And the expository nature of the script limits the cast in Bitter Christmas, the leads especially. They largely just explain the story. However, Aitana Sánchez-Gijón gives a sensationally good performance as Raúl’s friend, Mónica, whose betrayal over her amigo’s dramatic license ignites the film’s few dramatic fireworks. Ironically, she’s one of the few key characters who isn’t tethered to a keyboard.

Perhaps the prolific nature of Almodóvar’s filmography lends itself to the unexpected sluggishness with which Bitter Christmas plods. Almodóvar pitches it as a treatise on the complexities of auto-fiction, yet the self-assessing nature of the genre backfires. All the points about dramatic license and ethics are obvious ones. These are stories that Almodóvar has told before with far greater panache. Unless Pedro’s going a little too meta while telling audiences that he’s run out of things to say, his latest offering plays very been-there, done-that from one of cinema’s most original voices.

There’s a dash of Pain & Glory here and a splash of Talk to Her there. There are echoes of Julieta. Élsa and her friend, Patricia (Victoria Luengo), conspire about the latter’s cheating husband and make plans for a getaway. They listen to Chavela Vargas belt out a tune, which sounds like gears cranking to inspire a jolt similar to the one that Penélope Cruz gave with Volver’s deep and soulful ballad. Even the island that Élsa and Patricia visit just whisks Almodóvar fans back to the land of Broken Embraces and its tale of callbacks upon callbacks.

Bitter Christmas plays a lot like a movie that Woody Allen might deliver between cranking out the hits. The film evokes Almodóvar’s oeuvre just fine, but he’s repeating himself in a lesser key. Like Allen, though, his look to the past needs to provide more than simple inspiration for the present project. One hopes that this misfire is just a Scoop en route to Midnight in Paris.

When a director’s own filmography serves largely as the frame of reference for his new work, however, one can’t help but see such auto-fiction as mere navel gazing, particularly when Mónica reminds Raúl that movies aren’t everything. That truth may be as acrimonious as the tea from which Bitter Christmas gets its name. And the tea is piping hot.

Bitter Christmas opens in theatres beginning Nov. 20.



Advertisement