Joaquin Phoenix in Eddington

Let’s Talk About the Ending of Eddington

(This piece discusses major spoilers in Eddington )

Ari Aster’s Eddington plays as a sort of cinematic Rorschach test. Certain scenes and jokes will elicit laughs from half the audience, but leave others stone-faced. There’s no ideological slant to Eddington . The hyper-exaggerated satire takes no prisoners, taking shots at the expense of white girls just reading James Baldwin for the first time, as well as backwater deputies offering their opinions on race relations. Fans of Hereditary and Midsommar won’t have as much to relate to, but those attuned to Beau Is Afraid are likely to go along for the ride. Judging from the number of walkouts I noticed at my showing, and the lack of distance from COVID, your mileage may vary.

The camera lingers during encounters that were all too common five years ago. The Tribal Police come across Sheriff Joe (Joaquin Phoenix) and tell him he needs to wear a mask when he’s on their land. Sheriff Joe counters that they’re not even wearing the masks correctly, and that COVID isn’t even in town, but his talking points don’t land. All three men stare at each other until Sheriff Joe relents. With his tail tucked between his legs, Joe responds to a call outside the Mayor’s bar downtown.

The same incoherent, rambling drifter from the film’s beginning pounds on the door of Mayor Garcia’s (Pedro Pascal) bar. Mayor Garcia asks the Sheriff to move him off the property, but Sheriff Joe immediately chastises the Mayor for holding city council business when there are capacity limits posted on the door. While they argue, the drifter breaks through the glass door and starts guzzling whatever liquor he can find. Sheriff Joe goes to apprehend him, but the drifter throws him off, and Joe walks away with a limp for his troubles.

Phoenix plays Sheriff Joe with restraint, after going broad in two Joker films. The meek law enforcement officer hardly resembles the other bold characters Phoenix has played. He looks like every other guy you’d spot at a gas station. But that doesn’t mean he is without ambition. After watching an elderly man get turned away from the grocery store the next day, an opportunistic Joe seizes the moment. With cameras recording him, he verbally spars with Mayor Garcia and starts an anti-mask movement in Eddington.

Sheriff Joe and Mayor Garcia are the central focus of the film. Each man has a vision for a post-COVID Eddington, New Mexico. You could read the choice between both men as a metaphor for the flawed two-party system in the U.S. The Mayor pushes SolidGoldMagikarp as a tech-oriented future for a small town without any prospects. Sheriff Joe wants less “oppressive” laws and the free, open West that America has always promised. Both men are motivated by interests outside of their stated job. Joe can’t help but let past (or imagined) resentments colour all his encounters with the Mayor.

We hear throughout the film rumours that he and Joe’s wife, Louise (Emma Stone), had a relationship. The Mayor says he never touched her, but Louise’s “very online” mother (Deidre O’Connell) tells a story involving rape and an abortion. It’s hard to look at the Sheriff’s campaign as anything other than settling domestic scores. Conversely, the Mayor’s interests are mostly financial. He’s putting all his chips on a data centre that risks depleting the town’s last water resource.

Like any recent election, the race between Mayor Garcia and Sheriff Cross gets ugly and personal. When the Sheriff casts aspersions on Instagram, the Mayor’s son retaliates at rallies. Mutually assured destruction is supposed to be a deterrent, but neither man seems to care about collateral damage. Until this point, the film has just been a satire about poor behaviour during the pandemic. The third act raises the stakes considerably.

*Last chance to avoid spoilers*

Once Sheriff Joe gets slapped, responding to a noise complaint at the Mayor’s home, something cracks inside Phoenix’s character. The last straw, so to speak. Vernon Jefferson Peak (Austin Butler), an influencer obsessed with child trafficking, absconds with Louise, and BLM protests in town are a daily occurrence. But nothing happens at the most contentious arguments or protests. No, the Sheriff strikes when Pascal’s character is at home, sitting in his lounge chair, from far away. You see the flash first, and then the Mayor’s chest explodes with blood. His son comes into the room and gets shot when he realizes what happened. It’s not a crime of passion. Joe snipes both the Mayor and his teenage son in cold blood. Scooping up all the evidence and leaving BLM-inspired statements to throw investigators off his tracks. No one’s laughing at this point in Eddington .

At my showing, that was when five people left the auditorium.

Maybe Ari Aster wanted to share what scared him over the last five years. After a global pandemic, the scares in Hereditary and Midsommar probably seem quaint. The pandemic was difficult for everyone, regardless of political beliefs. People died. Businesses shut down. We couldn’t see friends and loved ones for months. Yet Eddington moves past those concerns to something exaggerated. Where Civil War played things close to the vest, Aster’s film delves headlong into the culture wars. While publicly denouncing the Mayor’s death, Sheriff Joe can’t help but challenge outside forces not to mess with him.

I don’t think it’s a coincidence that the appearance of the Antifa task force coincides with Sheriff Joe getting COVID. The private jet they arrive in is the fakest thing in Eddington . Adorned with a giant fist clutching Earth in its grasp, the jet is clearly intended to represent the Globalists that conspiracy theorists talk about on Joe’s feed and his mother-in-law’s blogs. The film, until that point, creates a very grounded and realistic-looking small-town America. Once Antifa shows up, the film more closely resembles a fever dream, filled with Rambo -esque action. It’s plausible that the film posits everything as the collective hallucination of a fringe group prone to spending too much time on social media. You never see any of the agitators outside of brief flashes, and only Phoenix’s character finds the cell phone with all the damning evidence of a massive Globalist conspiracy.

Again, that’s just one reading. One audience member chose to yell out “Soros” as all this happened.

Eddington doesn’t have to stand for only one reading. Maybe it’s simpler than that. The film might not be saying anything at all. Perhaps there is nothing to learn from the chaos and craziness of the whole ordeal. Maybe the horror of Eddington is that cruelty and brutality exist for no reason.

Or maybe the message is smaller, less politically charged.

Given that the film starts with an incoherent drifter walking past a billboard for a forthcoming data centre and then ends with that data centre lit up like an oasis in the desert, maybe that’s Eddington ’s true goal. Given all the craziness, it’s easy to lose sight that SolidGoldMagikarp may have been the only intention. Maybe the film serves as a reminder that—whatever political factions say and do—ultimately, the interests of the ultra-wealthy are the only priority in the U.S.

Eddington is out in theatres nationwide now.



Advertisement