Eva Noblezaba, André De Shields, and Reeve Carney in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesy of Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment

Hadestown: The Musical Review: A Gold Standard for Filmed Theatre

“It’s an old song, and we’re going to sing it again.”

In 2010, singer-songwriter Anaïs Mitchell released a folk opera concept album that took the classic Greek myths of Orpheus and Eurydice and set them to a combination of modern American folk music and New Orleans-inspired jazz. Mitchell would spend the next few years further fleshing out her concept before it eventually debuted on Broadway in 2019 to rave reviews and accolades.

Now, over 15 years since that initial concept album, Hadestown: The Musical presents a live recording of a performance of the smash-hit musical from London’s Lyric Theatre. Recorded over three nights, the film reunites five of the original Broadway cast members, including Reeve Carney ( House of Gucci , Penny Dreadful ), André De Shields ( Rescue Me , Tick, Tick…Boom! ), Amber Gray ( Escape at Dannemora , The Gilded Age ), Eva Noblezada ( Luck ), and Patrick Page ( In The Heights , Spirited ), returning to the roles they originated in New York. For fans of the musical, it’s perhaps the greatest gift they could ask for. For newcomers, like myself, it’s perhaps the ideal way to be introduced to this theatrical marvel. From the end of the first number, it’s easy to see why Hadestown has become so revered for theatre lovers across the globe; this show is absolutely electric!

Eva Noblezaba and Reeve Carney in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesyof Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment
Eva Noblezaba and Reeve Carney in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesy of Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment

For those unfamiliar, Hadestown: The Musical “invites audiences on a hell-raising journey to the underworld and back”, and transposes those ancient tales to a post-apocalyptic/depression era New Orleans-inspired setting. Written by Mitchell and directed by Rachel Chavkin (perhaps best known outside of Hadestown for directing the award-winning musical Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 ), the Broadway production would go on to be nominated for fourteen Tony Awards, winning eight, including Best Musical and Best Original Score. Admittedly, the material is a bit more challenging than some of the more recent popular musicals, and there’s a much higher level of theatricality on display here. But that’s also what makes it so special and compelling: this is a truly unique piece of musical theatre.

It can be a challenge reviewing these “pro shot” live theatre performances as films, as they are acting as both a narrative feature and a documentation of a live event. So this begs the question: do you review the production itself, or the resulting film? And what do you do if one is stronger than the other? In this case, I’m thrilled to say that either way Hadestown: The Musical is a triumph. Not only is the musical itself sensational, and unlike any other show seen before, but the film itself stands as one of the best examples of filmed theatre in recent memory; a new gold standard for how these types of films should be done.

Eva Noblezaba and Reeve Carney in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesyof Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment
Eva Noblezaba and Reeve Carney in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesy of Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment

On top of all that, as previously mentioned, you get to see five of the key members of the original Broadway production revive their roles on the big screen. Each was nominated for a major theatre acting award for Hadestown , with André De Shields winning a Tony Award for Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Role in a musical. They have spent years with the show and understand these characters perhaps better than anyone, so it’s not surprising that their performances are perfectly calibrated. And while each turns in commanding performances, it is Eva Noblezada who steals the show. From the first moment she opens her mouth, absolute magic pours out; her Act Two showstopper “Flowers” is unquestionably one of the most impressive and moving pieces of musical theatre performance I’ve ever seen (and I would argue perhaps the best performance you’ll see on screen this year).

One must also shout out the actor playing Hades himself, Patrick Page, who, days before the show was set to begin, injured himself, rupturing his Achilles tendon. Bringing new meaning to the old adage “the show must go on”, Page donned a walking cast and performed the show from top to bottom, including a truly haunting and moving dance number near the end of the show. It’s a testament to the actor’s commitment to their craft, and the end results are remarkable.

Patrick Page and Amber Gray in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesy ofBleecker Street and LD Entertainment
Patrick Page and Amber Gray in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesy of Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment

But perhaps the greatest thing about this Hadestown experience is that rather than allowing the stage-show’s director to direct the filmed performance, something we’ve seen with the filmed productions of Hamilton and the recent revival of Merrily We Roll Along , a proper veteran of the medium was tapped to capture the production in all its glory. Brett Sullivan previously directed the filmed versions of Billy Elliot The Musical, Love Never Dies, Miss Saigon: 25th Anniversary, Newsies: The Broadway Musical, Waitress , and most recently Frozen: The Hit Broadway Musical, and he is also currently working on the filmed version of the stage adaptation of Stranger Things for Netflix. In other words, this is someone who not only understands film but, perhaps even more importantly, also knows how to best capture a stage performance for the big screen. And the end result is truly night and day.

Reeve Carney and André De Shields in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICALCourtesy of Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment
Reeve Carney and André De Shields in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesy of Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment

In my review of the filmed production of Merrily We Roll Along , I complained about the way that film seemed to want to eschew any sense that it was a stage show, with an overuse of close-ups and a lack of a sense of place. Sullivan’s film doesn’t suffer from any of those problems; he’s not afraid to show the audience or mechanics of the stage setting when appropriate (the film itself opens with backstage glimpses of the cast preparing to perform the show). More importantly, he is able to employ the things that make film unique from theatre to the film’s benefit. There’s energy to the cinematography and the editing — an energy that complements Mitchell’s music, Chavkin’s Tony Award-winning direction, and David Neumann’s choreography. There are dynamics to the shot design and cutting form. The film perfectly captures and complements Bradley King’s Tony Award-winning lighting design in glorious high definition. Best of all, it gives the audience the ability to see details that would only ever be glimpsed in a live setting. It’s in those moments that the film shines the brightest.

Reeve Carney in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesy of Bleecker Streetand LD Entertainment
Reeve Carney in HADESTOWN: THE MUSICAL Courtesy of Bleecker Street and LD Entertainment

This isn’t just watching “from the front row” as the trailer heralds; this is, in many ways, better than being there. This is using the medium of cinema to elevate the live performance. Simply put, audiences are in great hands with Sullivan and his team behind the lens. Whether you’re a long-time fan of the original show or visiting the underworld for the first time, Hadestown: The Musical will win you over with its thrilling songs, show-stopping performances, and stunning production. Moreover, this is easily the best “pro shot” I’ve seen in some time, and I raise my cup to it; and fans of the show will be absolutely ecstatic getting to witness it on the big screen. So don’t wait! See it on the biggest screen possible while you can.

Hadestown: The Musical opens in theatres for a limited engagement July 24.



Advertisement