Super Mario Maker 2 Review

An extremely satisfying Mario experience in every way

When Nintendo ported the original Super Mario Maker to the Nintendo 3DS, the idea was to get more people to play it because the Wii U at that point was dead in the water. I enjoyed the port despite the small screen, and sales proved that a sequel was in fact needed, and what better place than on the Nintendo Switch? Thankfully, not only does the sequel improve on many aspects of the first game but does so with all the charisma of a mainline Mario game.

Super Mario Maker 2 is very much like the first game albeit with some new additions. My favourite addition is Story Mode. With Mario and several Toads having finished rebuilding Peach’s Castle, the precocious Undodog accidentally causes the castle to disappear. Now, it’s up to Mario with the help of the Toads to earn coins across 100 new levels designed by Nintendo and rebuild the castle according to Chief Toadette’s specifications.

Let Me Tell You a Story

Not lasting longer than six hours, Story Mode works well as an integrated tutorial. You’ll learn more about the tools Nintendo includes in the game while progressing through the story. It’s easier to make Courses after completing Story Mode. What really caught my attention was how excellent each Story Mode level was with each one providing an exciting thrill and challenge.

Like its predecessor, Super Mario Maker, the basic idea here is to allow your creativity to bloom. By handing over the keys to their development tools, you’re able to craft your own 2D Super Mario adventure by designing your own levels, or heading over to Course World, where you can share, download and rate creations from all over the world. Some are fun, others are sadistic and offer tons of replayability.


And like its predecessor, levels are created in a variety of different styles: Super Mario Bros, Super Mario Bros 3, Super Mario World, and New Super Mario Bros. U. So many bits and pieces make up each style, you’ll often have a hard time deciding which one works best. Of course, each style also has a ton of personality and its great how Nintendo incorporates each style of Mario game into one video game.

Course Maker, Make Me A Course

As for creating new courses, the new additions are most welcome. Nintendo added a new style for the sequel and it’s possibly my favourite. Using the Super Mario 3D World Style, one I found to be underrated and underused, means we get more Cat Mario! This is not the full 3D design, but the elements are included and moved to the 2D plane. So, if you’re expecting to recreate full 3D worlds, you won’t find that here. Maybe in Super Mario Maker 3?

One of the best things about Super Mario Maker 2 is Yamamura’s Dojo. It is here that you’ll learn from the genius course maker who happens to be a pigeon. Yamamura elaborates and teaches you what to do when using the course creator. The Dojo is entirely optional but also offers some of the best advice for creating courses and includes three skills levels when learning the ropes – Beginner, Intermediate, and Advanced. Some of the topics range using parts to Mario’s limitations and clear conditions.

Nintendo also includes several new things like being able to add slopes to your course, the Angry Sun from Super Mario Bros. 3, Snake Block, an on/off switch, seesaw, swinging claw, water level, and the ability to custom scroll your course. There’s more than enough new content and I’ve barely scratched the surface on the new inclusions to the editor. At the top of your screen in Course Maker are 12 blocks, each with their own building material. One might be for Mario’s starting point, while the next might be for a power-up, another for coins, warp pipes and so on. Pressing Y opens a sub-menu with more level building tools like Terrain, Items, Enemies, and Gizmos. Every aspect can be customized to your level including the size, colour, and how the level reacts to Mario.


When it comes to creating a course, it can be done in a few ways. To start, the touchscreen is ideal, and a controller works but it isn’t the best way to create a course. Nintendo reworked and improved controls for the editor, but it still leaves a little to be desired. In Maker 2, shortcuts alleviate minor controller issues, and the included radial menu allows for easier selection on the fly.

Stylus Recommended

The touchscreen is a lot more intuitive and depending on your preference, a stylus is worth investing in if you plan on creating many courses. However, it isn’t necessary as Nintendo has improved and streamlined the process of course creation and feels a lot better than I remember in the original Maker. Placement is easier with a finger for example, and usually ends up where I want it to be. Nintendo also added the ability to add a clear condition to a level, and some of them are dastardly and exciting. One condition might see Mario unable to jump during a level or another you need to collect all the coins. The conditions are left to the creator and each level either offers clear conditions or doesn’t.

My first level took me roughly an hour and a half to make but offers little incentive to play it. Learning the ropes of course making takes some time and thanks to the excellent Story Mode, the inspiration is there.

Jumping into Course World is where I had the most fun. In the pre-release of Super Mario Maker 2, dozens of levels are already available for consumption and range in difficulty. One level in pre-release called Slide and Ride sees Mario use a kart to complete the level while collecting all coins. Each level can be rated on whether you “like it,” or “boo!” Comments are published to the internet for all to see and offer insight on the level you’re commenting on.


On the hunt for good Courses

A detailed search offers one of the better ways to explore all the levels people create. Choosing the Game Style, Course Theme, and Difficulty is one to go about finding the best levels. Another way is by Region and lastly by Tag: Standard, Puzzle-solving, Speedrun, Autoscroll, Short and sweet, and Multiplayer Versus to name a few.

Speaking of Multiplayer, Network Play is available, but you can’t play with friends. Nintendo is working on a fix to allow you to play with friends and not just strangers but for the time being it isn’t ready. Which is a shame that friends can’t test out your level that you’re working on and getting their feedback.


Super Mario Maker 2 improves on the established formula in every way and delivers an insanely satisfying Mario game. Loaded with over 100-Nintendo made courses, and all the tools to create your own, the fun won’t stop because you’ll end up making more of it. All the new features offer rewarding gameplay loops and the new themes and items end up creating memorable set pieces. If anything, this is what the original Super Mario Maker wanted to be at launch. I’m interested in seeing what the Nintendo community builds post launch of Super Mario Maker 2, those are the true testaments to creativity and where the real fun begins.

[A copy of the game was provided by the publisher for review purposes.]


This review first appeared on Console Creatures