The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping review: Tribute to Haymitch

How the Games began

The Hunger Games series captured audience’s imaginations, first in book form then as respectable film adaptations. The people of Panem joined Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence) in a rebellion before she even realized she was its leader. Their hearts broke with the many deaths that occurred during the games and in the fights for freedom that followed. Then author Suzanne Collins took everyone back in time to see how the ruthless President Snow lost his humanity, followed by a glimpse into the tragic life of District 12’s only victor for 25 years. Now, the latter is transporting its story to the big screen with The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping.

Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada) has never had a birthday that wasn’t also a reaping. Celebrations for his 16th year are characteristically short. His mom makes a special breakfast, his moonshine partner gifts him a bottle, and he spends the hours before the day’s big event with his girl, Leonore Dove (Whitney Peak). She gives him a beautiful pendant that doubles as a flint striker. A series of calamitous events puts Haymitch on the stage as one of District 12’s four tributes for the 50th annual Hunger Games. As the kids parade and train, Ampert (Percy Daggs IV), a boy from District 3, approaches Haymitch about an almost all-tribute alliance to take on the careers — and the Capitol.

The younger versions of characters that fans know from the original series are among this prequel’s most appealing aspects. Recognizable names surround Haymitch, both at home in District 12 and at the Capitol. This familiarity gives audiences an immediate connection to the narrative. It’s fascinating to see the vitality of some of the characters before President Snow (Ralph Fiennes) ground them down. This peek into the past also gives viewers a glimpse into how they forged some of those personalities, bonds and grudges.

The original Hunger Games film series did a commendable job developing the characters, even when they were destined to die. Audiences understood who most of them were before going into the arena, simultaneously raising the stakes and viewers’ connection to the individuals in the narrative. Unfortunately, that is a key element missing from this picture.

All the scenes leading up to the tributes’ arrival in the Capitol are brimming with emotion. But when they get there, it feels like the film is just going through the motions. It occasionally introduces a big personality, like forever-host Caesar Flickerman (Kieran Culkin), eccentric stylist Magno Stift (Billy Porter) or eternal optimist Effie Trinket (Elle Fanning). Then, it returns to skimming along the surface of a meticulously detailed novel. Even the events in the arena are condensed and lacking emotional depth.

Much like its predecessors, the training grounds offer a key location where tributes bond and understand the significance of a multi-district alliance. But the adaptation omits or only briefly references most of this context. This is also the environment that best reveals Ampert’s personality, but they diminish his role. These oversights weaken the audience’s engagement with the characters and consequently lessen the impact of their deaths in the arena. Just because everyone knows Haymitch is the victor doesn’t mean they should treat the lives of the other tributes as forfeit before it even begins. That goes against the narrative message that demands Panem value all children’s lives.

Nonetheless, these issues are not a reflection of the cast’s excellent performances. Each is well-suited to their role. Those taking on established characters match their counterparts’ personalities and physical appearances. Fanning is especially impressive in the larger-than-life role of District 12’s future escort, while Maya Hawke gets to reinvent Wiress to some degree.

Meanwhile, the newcomers mostly fit their characters’ literary descriptions, both physically and emotionally. Zada is endearing, building on all the goodwill Woody Harrelson previously brought to the character. But Glenn Close’s Joan Rivers-masquerade is marvellous as she portrays District 12’s escort, Drusilla Sickle, who aged out years earlier. The only misstep may be selecting Ben Wang as Haymitch’s fellow tribute from 12, Wyatt Callow. His performance is blameless, but Collins describes Wyatt as more physically imposing. Additionally, having recently made a heartbreaking appearance in the dystopian teen drama, The Long Walk, there may have been another less familiar choice.

Building on the performances, the costumes for their public appearances are both eccentric and stunning. The set designs also immerse viewers in Panem’s contrasting worlds. Although audiences don’t see much of District 12, it doesn’t appear to have changed much in the decades between victors. The area is still cloaked in an oppressive grey equally instilled by the Capitol and the mines. Similarly, the extravagant Capitol never misses an opportunity to flaunt its wealth and power. However, there are already consequential cracks in the city’s deference to authority. The tributes’ quarters have a 1970s aesthetic with warm, rustic colours like orange and deep purple. The arena is also a flawless representation of the lush and soothing landscape described in the book.

Unsurprisingly, the film concludes by linking this entry to the original series. Going beyond the chance to bring back some of the beloved characters, it becomes preoccupied with explaining how the older Haymitch avenged his younger self. However, it feels like filmmakers didn’t trust audiences to understand the correlation themselves, so they make it almost too explicit.

The first few moments in the arena in any of the franchise’s films are always heart-pounding. Then, the sheer magnitude of the cannon fire marking the children’s senseless deaths weighs heavily on everyone on- and off-screen. Although this film neglects its supporting characters, it remains an important entry in the series. It underlines Snow’s callousness, the extended grief that follows the Games and the merit of perseverance. That said, it would be interesting to see the initial four-hour cut of the film in the hopes that it pays the other tributes their dues.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens in theatres November 20.



Advertisement